Kaely 2Pcs Black Gel Eyeliner Pencil,Herbal Black Eyeliner Cream Water resistant Smudge Evidence,Eye Liner Black Smokey Eyeshadow Palette Stick Crayon,Goth Halloween Make-up,delineador de ojos contra el agua

Like but
It’s not waterproof and it smudges to much for me.

4.5 stars. I love these eyeliners, but probably not for the regular reasons.
First, I’m not an eyeshadow user. The only makeup I use (and I’m leaning up hard against 63) is eyeliner (mostly pencil, sometimes liquid) and dark red lipstick (preferably the long-last kind). I’m not sure why, because I’ve been retired for 4.5 years and only go out for doctor appointments, but… I don’t like walking into my bathroom, looking into my mirror, and thinking “aaaaak!” I confess this makes me strange. But this is why I wear makeup at home.Most of my makeup routine is skincare. I need dark red lipstick to bring color to my face, and I need eyeliner to bring out my eyes. I don’t wear mascara because it’s a big fat waste of time & money for me. My lashes are short, sparse, thin, and worst of all, fine. Mascara doesn’t even cling to my eyelashes. Who ever heard of that? And I’m a minimalist, but blush, bronzer, concealer, foundation… more aaaak! I’m too lazy to do all that.Anyway, Kaely eyeliner. I love the aesthetics of the containers. So cute! I love the eyeliner crayon. It takes no time at all to get a smoky eye. I just use a cotton swab and micellar water to wipe the residue clean. I love this product because, although it smears on my upper lid (I have hooded eyelids), the smears look intentional. This product is waterproof. It does tend to smudge, but if I have to go out, I carry a mirror, a tiny bottle of micellar water and cotton swabs with me.My skin is tan and my hair is (still) black, and the gray liner is amazing on me. The black is a bit more dramatic, so I use a lighter hand with it. But really, this may be the easiest eye makeup for me out there, and it’s inexpensive! Removal of makeup at night is easy: I rub Ponds cold cream over lips, eyes, and face, take a warm damp washcloth, rest it on my face, and then rub the cream off. My skin is soft and ready for serum and eye cream.I think I only docked the one star because of the smudgeability of this product, but I really rate it a 4.5. If you’re into the smoky, minimalist eye or easy products, you owe it to yourself to try this. I think you’ll be surprisingly pleased. Thank you.

Beautiful color & easy to apply
I got dark green and light purple liners and was a bit skeptical as these colors can be tricky but pleasantly surprised with the quality and ease of application of this liner. It stays put whole day and i am very happy with the colors i got. Good value for money as well. Highly recommended.

bothered my eyes
I was excited to try this product. Ive been a big fan of eye liner all my adult life. I have tried so many different brands and styles. I was excited to see the examples of the pigmentation and ease of this product. I felt when I did have it on – it bothered my eyes and caused them to water a lot. It was kind of annoying to constantly be trying to adjust my vision. To me, it is not 100% smudge proof nor 100% waterproof. I had issues throughout the day of dark smears on my face. I put this product on and went to work and had not even touched my face or eyes (this was prior to the irritation) and when I got to work I noticed it was all over my under eye in the incorrect place. I will use sparingly and not as a daily go-to eye product.